Redpath Insights

businesscalculationvsvaluationreports

The Difference Between Business Calculation & Valuation Reports

by Emmett Mulcahy, CPA, CVA

If you have ever used a CPA firm for attestation work, you may be familiar with the three levels of financial statement service: audit, review, and compilation. Each of these levels of service offers a different degree of assurance, and determining the right level of service is dependent on the facts and circumstances of each business ownerโ€™s situation.

Similarly, a business valuation analyst also offers different levels of serviceโ€”a calculation engagement and a valuation engagement. A proper understanding of the differences between these engagements and the corresponding business valuation reports produced will help facilitate better conversations between the business owner and their valuation analyst. The outcome of those conversations will help ensure that the right level of service is being performed for the business owner based on their unique needs.

Valuation Blog Series 2 of 6
Valuation Series 1: What Factors Contribute to the Valuation of a Company?

Valuation Series 3: Business Valuation Approaches: Asset, Income and Market Approach
Valuation Series 4: Standard of Value: Recognizing the Differences

Types of Valuation Engagements

The American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) in their Statement on Standards for Valuation Services (SSVS) defines the two types of business valuation engagements as the following:

Business Calculation Engagement

A valuation analyst performs a calculation engagement when:

(1)  the valuation analyst and the client agree on the valuation approaches and methods the valuation analyst will perform in the process of calculating the value of the subject interest (these procedures will be more limited than those for a valuation engagement), and

(2)  the valuation analyst calculates the value in compliance with the agreement.

Since a calculation engagement will not include all of the procedures required for a valuation engagement, the analyst will express the results of their procedures as a calculation of value. A calculation of value may be suitable for strategic planning, non-contested divorce cases, or executing a buy/sell agreement.

Business Valuation Engagement

A valuation analyst performs a valuation engagement when:

(1)  the engagement calls for the valuation analyst to estimate the value of the subject interest, and

(2)  the valuation analyst estimates the value and is free to apply the valuation approaches and methods they deem appropriate considering the circumstances.

The valuation analyst expresses the results of the valuation as a conclusion of value. A conclusion of value is required for gift and estate tax filings.

Calculation v Valuation

Engagement Differences

Reasonable Assumptions

Aside from the agreement of procedures and methods to be utilized within a business valuation report, the main difference between the two levels of service is the allowance of reasonable assumptions to be utilized in a calculation engagement. In the context of a calculation engagement, a reasonable assumption can be the basis for critical valuation inputs such as rates of return, market multiples, and discounts for lack of marketability or lack of control, along with many other factors.

Cost

The use of reasonable assumptions is also what enables the calculation engagement to be performed at a lower costโ€”and in a more condensed time frameโ€”relative to a valuation engagement. However, the calculation engagement also comes at the cost of less analysis contained within the report. It is this trade-off between cost and depth of analysis that is essential for business owners to understand when deciding which level of service is appropriate for their specific valuation needs.

 

Click here to read our ebook on Business Valuation

 

Defensibility

Business owners and valuation analysts will weigh cost considerations, timing, data limitations, and other factors against the defensibility of any end product produced by the valuation analyst. Given the differences in levels of diligence and analysis between the two types of engagements, the results of a calculation engagement may not hold the same weight as the results of a valuation engagement. Determining if that trade-off is acceptable will come down to the reasons for needing a value of the business.

A calculation engagement may be appropriate for planning purposes, initial buy/sell agreements, preliminary negotiations, merger and acquisition activity, and other instances when opinions of value from a valuation analyst donโ€™t need to hold up to scrutiny to some sort of authority.

While calculation engagements are useful for a multitude of reasons, valuation engagements should be utilized in any instance when the value of a business needs to be determined for some authority figure. Examples include:

  • Business values submitted to the IRS. Business values generally demand a conclusion of value, especially in instances where the business is being valued for charitable contributions or gift and estate purposes. It should also be noted that the IRS has its own adequate disclosure rules for gift taxes. While a calculation engagement may not meet those rules and requirements, a conclusion of value determined through a valuation engagement should meet those requirements (and is what the IRS expects to receive).
  • Valuation work performed for legal proceedings. Rules of evidence can apply in legal proceedings, and the results will be scrutinized by a judge (or compared to work done by an opposing expert).
  • Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP) valuations. ESOP valuations are reviewed by the Department of Labor and should be performed as valuation engagements. This helps ensure that the resulting conclusions are held in the highest regard by third parties and that the opinions derived by the analyst are fully defensible when tested.

The inherent differences between a valuation engagement and calculation engagement are important for business owners to understand as they weigh their options when engaging with a valuation professional. This understanding will help facilitate better discussions with the valuation analyst and will provide the best outcomes that meet their specific and unique needs.

Read Part 1 of this series: What Factors Contribute to the Valuation of a Company?
Read Part 3 of this series: Business Valuation Approaches: Asset, Income and Market Approach
Read Part 4 of this series: Standard of Value: Recognizing the Differences

Emmett Mulcahy, CPA, CVA

Emmett Mulcahy, CPA, CVA

Emmett Mulcahy is a director and leads the valuation service area at Redpath and Company. He assists clients with business valuations for ESOP, estate and gift tax, shareholder buyout, buy/sell agreement and transaction consulting purposes. Emmett works with a variety of clients in industries such as construction, architects and engineers, family limited partnerships, manufacturing, and real estate. He has provided public accounting services at Redpath and Company since 2008.