Redpath Insights

The Potential Impact of Tax Reform on Choice of Entity

by John Kammerer, CPA

On November 2nd, the House GOP released the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. While the Act still has some major hurdles to clear before it becomes law, many business owners are already beginning to analyze the potential impact to them and their businesses. The Act is very broad and would impact a wide range of areas. After our initial review of the Act, it appears the choice of entity could be one of the most significant areas business owners will have to analyze.

Background on Choice of Entity Decision

Generally, businesses have a choice to be taxed as

  • a C corporation, where the entity is responsible for paying the tax, or
  • a pass-through entity (S corporation or Partnership) where the individual owner of the entity is responsible for paying the tax.

A number of factors impact this decision, including

  • the number and types of owners,
  • the jurisdictions in which the business operates,
  • the type of business and industry, and
  • the desired tax treatment.

Under current law, many businesses benefit by choosing to be taxed as pass-through entities. The primary reasons are that

  • pass-through entities are not subject to "double tax" (where the income is taxed by the corporation and then again by the owners when it is paid out as a dividend), and
  • pass-through entities are able to utilize the capital gain tax rate on the eventual sale of the assets of the businesses.

Changes in Tax Cuts and Jobs Act

Among the many changes impacting businesses and their owners, the tax rate changes and the limitation on the ability of individuals to deduct state and local income taxes result in some significant changes to the analysis.

Under the Act, C corporation tax rates would be reduced from a top rate of 35% to a flat tax rate of 20%. In addition, the tax rate on pass-through entities was reduced from a top rate of 39.6% to a top rate of 25%. However, the 25% rate only applies to the portion of the taxable income considered to be related to capital which under the general rule is 30% (0% for certain service businesses). The regular rates, as well as self-employment taxes, will apply to the remaining income. For passive owners, the 25% rate will apply to all of the income.

The following example helps illustrate the potential impact of the law changes of a business operated as a C corporation and an S corporation under both the current law and the new law. To simplify the comparison, the calculation below assumes that the shareholders are active in the business, not subject to state tax, and subject to the top rates. The calculation also assumes that all the activity qualifies for the domestic production deduction.

The potential impact of the law changes of a business operated as a C corporation and an S corporation under both the current law and the new law.

As the calculation illustrates, the proposed changes have the potential to increase taxes on businesses operating as pass-through entities. There are a number of factors that can impact the analysis for individual taxpayers, including

  • the state taxes generated by the entity;
  • the type of business deductions generated under current law; and
  • whether the owner is active in the business, etc.

C corporations stand to benefit significantly from the proposed law. Company level taxes would decrease significantly and the spread between the taxes on operating profit from a C corporation to an S corporation would increase compared to current law. While the effect of the second level of tax still results in a higher tax overall, the timing of that tax can be controlled and the impact is decreasing.

Conclusion

Ultimately, there are still a lot of things to consider in the choice of entity analysis. As we approach year end, we are carefully monitoring the tax reform bill and the potential impact to our clients. If the Act were to pass without substantial modification, many of our clients would need to consider whether their current entity type still makes sense.

John Kammerer, CPA

John Kammerer, CPA

John Kammerer is a partner at Redpath and Company and holds a seat on the firm’s board of directors. He leads the firm’s business tax service area, assisting clients with tax planning and preparation, research, entity structuring, and M&A transactions. John works with a variety of clients in industries such as manufacturing, construction, real estate, and professional services. He is a frequent presenter on topics of business taxation and entity structuring. John is also a member of the S Corp Association advisory board and is actively involved with the group to promote and support tax policies that positively impact S Corporations and privately-held businesses. John graduated from Winona State University with a Bachelor of Science degree in Accounting. He is a member of the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) and the Minnesota Society of Certified Public Accountants (MNCPA). He has provided public accounting services at Redpath and Company since 2004.